PREMIUM COIN AUCTION | Live and Online Auctions on HiBid.com

PREMIUM COIN AUCTION
Online Only Auction

Bontrager Real Estate & Auction

8975 Wortendyke Rd
Batavia, NY 14020
 

Date(s) 9/22/2020 - 9/29/2020

STARTS: Tuesday, September 22nd at 9 a.m. ENDS: Tuesday, September 29th at 4 p.m. Internet Bidding Only

Past Auction
Online-Only Auction
Shipping Available
Auction Details
Preview
Auction Preview
Bidding Notice:

-Internet Bidding Only -All payments by credit/debit card except for gold. Gold purchasers must pay with certified bank check.

Auction Notice:

PAYMENT: All payments will automatically be charged to the buyer's credit card. Declined credit cards will require a bank check (no personal checks) payment unless otherwise approved by the auctioneer. Buyers of gold must pay with certified bank check (credit/debit will not be accepted for gold purchases). MERCHANDISE PICKUP DATE: Thursday, October 1st: 9 a.m .- 11 a.m. and 4 p.m. - 6 p.m., ... Show More

Show Search Bar
Quick Search
Category
All Categories (0)
Single Page
Showing 1 to 100 of 258 lots
Lot 1 |

HOW TO REGISTER & BID: *Read, don’t bid here*
HOW TO REGISTER & BID: *Read, don’t bid here*
Lot 2 |

TERMS: *Read, but don’t bid here*
TERMS: *Read, but don’t bid here*
Lot 3 |

CREDIT/DEBIT PAYMENT ONLY: *Read, don’t bid here*
CREDIT/DEBIT PAYMENT ONLY: *Read, don’t bid here*
Lot 4 |

PICK UP BY APPOINTMENT: *Read, don’t bid here*
PICK UP BY APPOINTMENT: *Read, don’t bid here*
Lot 5 |

SHIPPING: *Read, don’t bid here*
SHIPPING: *Read, don’t bid here*
Lot 6 |

NOT GETTING OUR EMAILS? Read, don’t bid here
NOT GETTING OUR EMAILS? Read, don’t bid here
Lot 7 |

(2) MORGAN SILVER DOLLARS: 1881 & 1883-S
(2) MORGAN SILVER DOLLARS: 1881 & 1883-S
Price Realized:
102.00 USD / Lot
51.00 USD / ea
Lot 8 |

(26) INDIAN HEAD/BUFFALO NICKELS:
(26) INDIAN HEAD/BUFFALO NICKELS:
Price Realized:
22.00 USD
Lot 9 |

(2) AMERICAN SILVER EAGLES: 1991 & 2002
(2) AMERICAN SILVER EAGLES: 1991 & 2002
Price Realized:
78.00 USD / Lot
39.00 USD / ea
Lot 10 |

(2) AMERICAN SILVER EAGLES: 1998 & 1999
(2) AMERICAN SILVER EAGLES: 1998 & 1999
Price Realized:
80.00 USD / Lot
40.00 USD / ea
Lot 11 |

(2) 2002-S STATE QUARTERS: OHIO & MICHIGAN
(2) 2002-S STATE QUARTERS: OHIO & MICHIGAN
Price Realized:
10.00 USD
Lot 12 |

JANUARY 15, 1862 STATE OF GEORGIA (MILLEDGEVILLE)
JANUARY 15, 1862 STATE OF GEORGIA (MILLEDGEVILLE)
Price Realized:
29.00 USD
Lot 13 |

1991 AMERICAN SILVER EAGLE
1991 AMERICAN SILVER EAGLE
Price Realized:
33.00 USD
Lot 14 |

(2) 2002-S STATE QUARTERS: OHIO & MICHIGAN
(2) 2002-S STATE QUARTERS: OHIO & MICHIGAN
Price Realized:
11.00 USD
Lot 15 |

1891-CC MORGAN $1
1891-CC MORGAN $1
Price Realized:
90.00 USD
Lot 15a |

1856 FLYING EAGLE CENT, PROOF VF DETAILS (NGC)
1856 FLYING EAGLE CENT, PROOF VF DETAILS (NGC)
Price Realized:
6,400.00 USD
Lot 16 |

1854 HALF DIME & 1840-O HALF DIME (NO DRAPERY)
1854 HALF DIME & 1840-O HALF DIME (NO DRAPERY)
Price Realized:
13.00 USD
Lot 17 |

(2) 2002-S STATE QUARTERS: CALIFORNIA & OHIO
(2) 2002-S STATE QUARTERS: CALIFORNIA & OHIO
Price Realized:
8.00 USD
Lot 18 |

1995 ELVIS PRESLEY $5 COMMEMORATIVE COIN AND
1995 ELVIS PRESLEY $5 COMMEMORATIVE COIN AND
Price Realized:
5.00 USD
Lot 19 |

2002-S OHIO QUARTER (NGC SLAB PF-69UC),
2002-S OHIO QUARTER (NGC SLAB PF-69UC),
Price Realized:
3.00 USD
Lot 20 |

1878-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (ICG)
1878-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (ICG)
Price Realized:
92.50 USD
Lot 21 |

1878 7TF REV. 79 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
1878 7TF REV. 79 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
65.00 USD
Lot 22 |

1879 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS63 (NGC)
1879 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS63 (NGC)
Price Realized:
75.00 USD
Lot 23 |

1879-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS61 (NGC)
1879-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS61 (NGC)
Price Realized:
75.00 USD
Lot 24 |

1879-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64 (ICG)
1879-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64 (ICG)
Price Realized:
60.00 USD
Lot 25 |

1878-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, GEM BU (RAW COIN)
1878-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, GEM BU (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
72.50 USD
Lot 25a |

1911 $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
1911 $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
Price Realized:
300.00 USD
Lot 26 |

1879-S REV. 79 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
1879-S REV. 79 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
33.00 USD
Lot 27 |

1879-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
1879-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
33.00 USD
Lot 28 |

1879-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
1879-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
41.00 USD
Lot 29 |

1880 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS61 (NGC)
1880 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS61 (NGC)
Price Realized:
46.00 USD
Lot 30 |

1880 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (NGC)
1880 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (NGC)
Price Realized:
47.00 USD
Lot 31 |

1880 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
1880 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
32.00 USD
Lot 32 |

1880-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS65 (PCGS)
1880-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS65 (PCGS)
Price Realized:
160.00 USD
Lot 33 |

1881 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (NGC)
1881 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (NGC)
Price Realized:
65.00 USD
Lot 34 |

1881 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
1881 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
90.00 USD
Lot 35 |

1881-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (ICG)
1881-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS62 (ICG)
Price Realized:
46.00 USD
Lot 35a |

1912 $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
1912 $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
Price Realized:
300.00 USD
Lot 36 |

1881-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS63 (NGC)
1881-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS63 (NGC)
Price Realized:
77.50 USD
Lot 37 |

1786 COLONIAL NEW JERSEY COPPER PCGS VF20
1786 COLONIAL NEW JERSEY COPPER PCGS VF20
Price Realized:
400.00 USD
Lot 38 |

1912-S LIBERTY NICKEL PCGS VG08
1912-S LIBERTY NICKEL PCGS VG08
Price Realized:
120.00 USD
Lot 39 |

1882 SEATED LIBERTY DIME NGC MS66
1882 SEATED LIBERTY DIME NGC MS66
Price Realized:
700.00 USD
Lot 40 |

1981 $10 FRN ERROR PMG GEM 65EPQ
1981 $10 FRN ERROR PMG GEM 65EPQ
Price Realized:
320.00 USD
Lot 41 |

1771 COLONIAL TEN SHILLINGS "PROVINCE OF NORTH
1771 COLONIAL TEN SHILLINGS "PROVINCE OF NORTH
Price Realized:
300.00 USD
Lot 42 |

GIORI TEST NOTE, 1970's WASHINGTON CENTER
GIORI TEST NOTE, 1970's WASHINGTON CENTER
Price Realized:
190.00 USD
Lot 43 |

1855-65 $10 NEW JERSEY, BORDENTOWN BANK CO.
1855-65 $10 NEW JERSEY, BORDENTOWN BANK CO.
Price Realized:
260.00 USD
Lot 44 |

1850's $1 BANKING HOUSE OF BALDWIN & DODGE,
1850's $1 BANKING HOUSE OF BALDWIN & DODGE,
Price Realized:
210.00 USD
Lot 45 |

2013-S SILVER EAGLE PCGS MS70 STRUCK AT
2013-S SILVER EAGLE PCGS MS70 STRUCK AT
Price Realized:
47.00 USD
Lot 45a |

1914-D $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
1914-D $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
Price Realized:
300.00 USD
Lot 46 |

1934-S PEACE SILVER DOLLAR "UNCIRCULATED"
1934-S PEACE SILVER DOLLAR "UNCIRCULATED"
Price Realized:
260.00 USD
Lot 47 |

1834 CORONET HEAD CENT "DOUBLED DIE FACE"
1834 CORONET HEAD CENT "DOUBLED DIE FACE"
Price Realized:
200.00 USD
Lot 48 |

1956-D ROOSEVELT DIME NGC MS66
1956-D ROOSEVELT DIME NGC MS66
Price Realized:
16.00 USD
Lot 49 |

1908-O BARBER SILVER HALF DOLLAR
1908-O BARBER SILVER HALF DOLLAR
Price Realized:
21.00 USD
Lot 50 |

1896 BARBER SILVER HALF DOLLAR
1896 BARBER SILVER HALF DOLLAR
Price Realized:
57.50 USD
Lot 51 |

1894-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR
1894-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR
Price Realized:
410.00 USD
Lot 52 |

1894-O MORGAN DOLLAR, TONED
1894-O MORGAN DOLLAR, TONED
Price Realized:
180.00 USD
Lot 53 |

1865 NICKEL 3 CENT PIECE, FIRST YEAR ISSUED
1865 NICKEL 3 CENT PIECE, FIRST YEAR ISSUED
Price Realized:
51.00 USD
Lot 54 |

1783 NOVA CONSTELLATIO "BLUNT RAYS" KEY VARIETY
1783 NOVA CONSTELLATIO "BLUNT RAYS" KEY VARIETY
Price Realized:
240.00 USD
Lot 55 |

1803 DRAPED BUST CENT "SMALL DATE, LARGE FRACTION"
1803 DRAPED BUST CENT "SMALL DATE, LARGE FRACTION"
Price Realized:
75.00 USD
Lot 55a |

1915 $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
1915 $2 1/2 GOLD INDIAN HEAD
Price Realized:
300.00 USD
Lot 56 |

1895-S MORGAN DOLLAR, KEY DATE
1895-S MORGAN DOLLAR, KEY DATE
Price Realized:
260.00 USD
Lot 57 |

1895-S MORGAN DOLLAR, KEY DATE
1895-S MORGAN DOLLAR, KEY DATE
Price Realized:
550.00 USD
Lot 58 |

1928 PEACE SILVER DOLLAR, KEY DATE
1928 PEACE SILVER DOLLAR, KEY DATE
Price Realized:
230.00 USD
Lot 59 |

1937-D BUFFALO NICKEL "3 LEGGED", KEY VARIETY
1937-D BUFFALO NICKEL "3 LEGGED", KEY VARIETY
Price Realized:
510.00 USD
Lot 60 |

1788 CENT MASSACHUSETTS, WITH PERIOD
1788 CENT MASSACHUSETTS, WITH PERIOD
Price Realized:
102.50 USD
Lot 61 |

1882 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64+ (ICG)
1882 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64+ (ICG)
Price Realized:
90.00 USD
Lot 62 |

1882-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, (RAW COIN)
1882-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
46.00 USD
Lot 63 |

1882-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 62 (NGC)
1882-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 62 (NGC)
Price Realized:
55.00 USD
Lot 64 |

1883 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 63 (NGC)
1883 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 63 (NGC)
Price Realized:
62.50 USD
Lot 65 |

1883-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 64 (NGC)
1883-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 64 (NGC)
Price Realized:
72.50 USD
Lot 66 |

1883-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 64 (PCGS)
1883-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 64 (PCGS)
Price Realized:
100.00 USD
Lot 67 |

1883-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, AU55 (NGC)
1883-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, AU55 (NGC)
Price Realized:
160.00 USD
Lot 68 |

1884 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS63 (NGC)
1884 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS63 (NGC)
Price Realized:
65.00 USD
Lot 69 |

1884-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 63 (NGC)
1884-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 63 (NGC)
Price Realized:
48.00 USD
Lot 70 |

1884-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, (RAW COIN)
1884-S MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, (RAW COIN)
Price Realized:
35.00 USD
Lot 71 |

1885 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64 (PCGS)
1885 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64 (PCGS)
Price Realized:
70.00 USD
Lot 72 |

1885-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 64 (NGC)
1885-O MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS 64 (NGC)
Price Realized:
80.00 USD
Lot 73 |

1935-A & 1957-A $1 SILVER CERTIFICATES
1935-A & 1957-A $1 SILVER CERTIFICATES
Price Realized:
16.00 USD
Lot 74 |

(2) 1969 PROOF SET & 1999 PROOF SET
(2) 1969 PROOF SET & 1999 PROOF SET
Price Realized:
18.00 USD / Lot
9.00 USD / ea
Lot 75 |

(4) CC MORGAN DOLLARS 1878, 1879, 1890, & 1891
(4) CC MORGAN DOLLARS 1878, 1879, 1890, & 1891
Price Realized:
640.00 USD / Lot
160.00 USD / ea
Lot 75a |

GOLD CASTING OF 1853 LIBERTY HEAD, PENDANT
GOLD CASTING OF 1853 LIBERTY HEAD, PENDANT
Price Realized:
13.00 USD
Lot 76 |

2000-P 1 OZ. AMERICAN EAGLE PROOF
2000-P 1 OZ. AMERICAN EAGLE PROOF
Price Realized:
32.00 USD
Lot 77 |

1965 & 1966 SPECIAL MINT SETS
1965 & 1966 SPECIAL MINT SETS
Price Realized:
16.00 USD / Lot
8.00 USD / ea
Lot 78 |

(20) DIFFERENT ITALY FOREIGN COINS
(20) DIFFERENT ITALY FOREIGN COINS
Price Realized:
13.00 USD
Lot 79 |

1921 MORGAN DOLLAR RING
1921 MORGAN DOLLAR RING
Price Realized:
15.00 USD
Lot 80 |

1964 MINT SET
1964 MINT SET
Price Realized:
20.00 USD
Lot 81 |

(4) FRANKLIN HALF DOLLARS;
(4) FRANKLIN HALF DOLLARS;
Price Realized:
60.00 USD / Lot
15.00 USD / ea
Lot 82 |

(20) VARIOUS FOREIGN COINS
(20) VARIOUS FOREIGN COINS
Price Realized:
13.00 USD
Lot 83 |

(6) SUSAN B. ANTHONY DOLLARS 1979 & 1980 P, D&S
(6) SUSAN B. ANTHONY DOLLARS 1979 & 1980 P, D&S
Price Realized:
7.00 USD
Lot 84 |

ORIENTAL COINS OF VARIOUS VINTAGE (15)
ORIENTAL COINS OF VARIOUS VINTAGE (15)
Price Realized:
16.00 USD
Lot 85 |

(250) MIXED COUNTRY FOREIGN COINS/DENOMINATIONS
(250) MIXED COUNTRY FOREIGN COINS/DENOMINATIONS
Price Realized:
26.00 USD
Lot 86 |

2017 1 OZ. SILVER AMERICAN EAGLE
2017 1 OZ. SILVER AMERICAN EAGLE
Price Realized:
31.00 USD
Lot 87 |

142 BC ROMAN (ANACS) VF35
142 BC ROMAN (ANACS) VF35
Price Realized:
85.00 USD
Lot 88 |

134 BC ROMAN SILVER, MINUCIUS AUGURINIS NGC
134 BC ROMAN SILVER, MINUCIUS AUGURINIS NGC
Price Realized:
72.50 USD
Lot 89 |

133 BC MYSIA PERGAMUM ROMAN RULE NGC XF
133 BC MYSIA PERGAMUM ROMAN RULE NGC XF
Price Realized:
200.00 USD
Lot 90 |

125 BC ROMAN REPUBLIC M PORCIUS LAECA, NGC,
125 BC ROMAN REPUBLIC M PORCIUS LAECA, NGC,
Price Realized:
120.00 USD
Lot 91 |

103 BC ROMAN REPUBLIC MINUCLUS THERMUS M.F.
103 BC ROMAN REPUBLIC MINUCLUS THERMUS M.F.
Price Realized:
67.50 USD
Lot 92 |

87 BC 87-80 BC PARTHINIAN KINGDOM MITHRADATES
87 BC 87-80 BC PARTHINIAN KINGDOM MITHRADATES
Price Realized:
170.00 USD
Lot 93 |

1913 BARBER HALF DOLLAR, NGC, PROOF 67+
1913 BARBER HALF DOLLAR, NGC, PROOF 67+
Price Realized:
4,000.00 USD
Lot 94 |

1886 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64 (ANACS)
1886 MORGAN SILVER DOLLAR, MS64 (ANACS)
Price Realized:
67.50 USD
Click for Fr8Star Freight ShippingGet Shipping Quotes