3rd Annual Mystery Christmas Auction
3rd Annual Mystery Christmas Auction
Flagship Collectibles | Westminster, MD 21157
Date(s) :  12/13/2024 - 12/15/2024
Buyer Premium :  20% Buyer's Premium


Online Only Auction
Live Auction Begins on 12/13
This is an online only auction with tons of Magic the Gathering, vintage 80s toys, sports cards and autographed items! Items will ship in time for Christmas.
1 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
2 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
3 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
4 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
5 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
6 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
7 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
8 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
9 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
10 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
11 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
12 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
13 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
14 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
15 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
16 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
17 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
18 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
19 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
20 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
21 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
22 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
23 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
24 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
25 1954 Topps Mystery Lot (TED WILLIAMS PSA 6) Estimate: 2,200.00 USD
One of 25 1954 Topps Mystery Lots. Winning bidders receives a 1954 Topps baseball card. One of the 25 winning bidders will receive a PSA 6 1954 Ted Williams.
26 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
27 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
28 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
29 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
30 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
31 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
32 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
33 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
34 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
35 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
36 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
37 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
38 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
39 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
40 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.
41 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
42 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
43 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
44 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
45 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
46 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
47 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
48 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
49 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
50 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
51 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
52 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
53 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
54 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
55 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
56 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
57 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
58 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
59 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
60 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
61 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
62 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
63 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
64 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
65 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
66 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
67 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
68 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
69 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
70 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
71 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
72 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
73 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
74 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
75 Autographed Mystery Lot Estimate: 100.00 - 1,200.00 USD
Contains an autographed item from MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, or Pop Culture.
76 Mystery Clothing Lot Estimate: 25.00 - 100.00 USD
Contains brand new clothing item(s) valued between $25 and $100.
77 Mystery Clothing Lot Estimate: 25.00 - 100.00 USD
Contains brand new clothing item(s) valued between $25 and $100.
78 Mystery Clothing Lot Estimate: 25.00 - 100.00 USD
Contains brand new clothing item(s) valued between $25 and $100.
79 Mystery Clothing Lot Estimate: 25.00 - 100.00 USD
Contains brand new clothing item(s) valued between $25 and $100.
80 Graded Sports Card Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Contains one PSA, SGC, or Beckett graded sports card. Cards included in this series are: autograph cards, rookies, patch, HOF, vintage & more.
81 Graded Sports Card Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Contains one PSA, SGC, or Beckett graded sports card. Cards included in this series are: autograph cards, rookies, patch, HOF, vintage & more.
82 Graded Sports Card Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Contains one PSA, SGC, or Beckett graded sports card. Cards included in this series are: autograph cards, rookies, patch, HOF, vintage & more.
83 Graded Sports Card Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Contains one PSA, SGC, or Beckett graded sports card. Cards included in this series are: autograph cards, rookies, patch, HOF, vintage & more.
84 Graded Sports Card Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Contains one PSA, SGC, or Beckett graded sports card. Cards included in this series are: autograph cards, rookies, patch, HOF, vintage & more.
85 Graded Sports Card Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Contains one PSA, SGC, or Beckett graded sports card. Cards included in this series are: autograph cards, rookies, patch, HOF, vintage & more.
86 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
87 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
88 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
89 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
90 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
91 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
92 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
93 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
94 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
95 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
96 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
97 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
98 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
99 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
100 250 Card MTG Mystery Lot Estimate: 50.00 - 400.00 USD
Includes 250 Magic: The Gathering cards pulled at random from a huge collection we recently purchased that includes thousands of rares, foil and vintage cards.
101 Vintage Toy Mystery Lot MOTU TMNT ++ Estimate: 20.00 - 250.00 USD
Contains a vintage action figure, vehicle and/or playset from MOTU, TMNT, Transformers, G.I. Joe and more. $20 minimum value. Possibilities include Castle Greyskull playset, Scare glow Skeletor and more.