HiBid.com is a great source of online auctions featuring popular five-cent coins, such as Shield nickels, Liberty Head nickels, Buffalo nickels, and Jefferson nickels. These coins have been minted since 1866, and while most have maximum values in the thousands of dollars, some extremely rare nickels can sell for millions. If you don’t see the item you’re looking for right now, check back again soon. Our website is continually updated, with new auction items in the U.S. Nickels category added often.

Nickels US For Sale - Live and Online Auction Lots

Proof 1996-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

1947-d Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ 5fs

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1973-d 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1999-p 40 pcs Bank $

Proof 1970-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

Proof 1998-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1988-p 40 pcs Bank $

1969-d Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Unc

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2003-p 40 pcs Dunbar

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1987-d 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1999-p 40 pcs N.F. S

NGC 1982-d Jefferson Nickel 5c Graded ms66 By NGC

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2005-p Ocean 40 pcs

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2008-d 40 pcs Bank $

Proof 1961 Jefferson Nickel TOP POP! 5c Graded pr6

1925-p Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades vg+

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1973-d 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1979-d 40 pcs Bank $

Proof 1999-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

Proof 1970-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1988-p 40 pcs Bank $

Proof 2000-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1980-p 40 pcs Bank $

Proof 1974-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

Proof 2002-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1979-p 40 pcs Bank $

Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2002-p 40 pcs String &

Proof 1988-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1999-p 40 pcs Dunbar

1997-p Jefferson Nickel Near Top Pop! 5c Graded ms

1947-d Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ 5fs

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2005-p Ocean 40 pcs

Proof 1992-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1979-p 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1979-d 40 pcs Bank $

Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll,2004-d Keel Boat 40 pcs

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2003-p 40 pcs Dunbar

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2002-p 40 pcs N.F. S

1954-p Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades Choice Unc+ 5fs

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2008-d 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1998-p 40 pcs N.F. S

Whitman Buffalo Nickels 1913-1938 Collectors Book

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1980-p 40 pcs Bank $

1935-p Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades f+

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1995-p 40 pcs Brandt

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2008-d 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1999-p 40 pcs Bank $

NGC 1982-d Jefferson Nickel 5c Graded ms66 By NGC

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2008-p 40 pcs N.F. S

Proof 2000-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2003-p 40 pcs N.F. S

1970-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM Unc PL

1936-d Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades vf+

1992-d Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM+ 6fs

1981-p Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Unc

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2002-p 40 pcs Dunbar

1937-s Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades vf+

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2002-p 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1999-p 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1973-d 40 pcs Bank $

***Auction Highlight*** 1992-d Jefferson Nickel Ne

Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2002-p 40 pcs N.F. Stri

Proof 1989-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

1914-d Buffalo Nickel 5c Grades vg, very good

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2008-p 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1964-p 40 pcs Bank $

***Auction Highlight*** 1992-p Jefferson Nickel Ne

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1999-p 40 pcs Bank $

Proof 2003-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1974-d 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2005-p Ocean 40 pcs

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2008-d 40 pcs Bank $

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1995-p 40 pcs Brandt

Proof 1997-s Jefferson Nickel 5c Grades GEM++ Proo

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1987-p 40 pcs Bank $

Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2002-p 40 pcs N.F. Stri

Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1998-p 40 pcs N.F. Stri

Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 1999-p 40 pcs N.F. Stri

BU Shotgun Jefferson 5c roll, 2003-p 40 pcs N.F. S

Auction Highlight 1992-d Jefferson Nickel Ne

Auction Highlight 1992-p Jefferson Nickel Ne