BATAVIA, NY COLLECTIBLES & ESTATES AUCTION | Live and Online Auctions on HiBid.com

BATAVIA, NY COLLECTIBLES & ESTATES AUCTION
Online Only Auction

Bontrager Real Estate & Auction

8975 Wortendyke Rd
Batavia, NY 14020

Map Opens in a new window

Date(s) 5/28/2026 - 6/3/2026

INTERNET BIDDING STARTS Thursday, May 28, 2026 at 9:00 am EST; ENDS Wednesday, June 3, 2026 at 6:00 pm EST (soft close).

Past Auction
Online Only Auction
Shipping Available
Auction Details
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW

Bidding Notice:

OUR POLICIES, PROCEDURES, AND ADDITIONAL FEES DIFFER FROM THOSE OF OTHER AUCTION COMPANIES. MAKE IT A PRIORITY TO READ OUR TERMS, SHIPPING, AND PICKUP INFORMATION.

Show Search Bar
Quick Search
Category
All Categories
Single Page
Showing 1 to 100 of 1,023 lots
Lot 1a |

BIDDING INSTRUCTIONS: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
BIDDING INSTRUCTIONS: WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
Price Realized Not Uploaded
Lot 1b |

IMPORTANT AUCTION TERMS AND CONDITIONS
IMPORTANT AUCTION TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Price Realized Not Uploaded
Lot 1c |

POLICY FOR SHIPPING OF FRAGILE ITEMS
POLICY FOR SHIPPING OF FRAGILE ITEMS
Price Realized Not Uploaded
Lot 1d |

ATTENTION TAX EXEMPT RESALE OR FARM BUYERS
ATTENTION TAX EXEMPT RESALE OR FARM BUYERS
Price Realized Not Uploaded
Lot 100 |

(5) United States Proof Sets, 1983–1987
(5) United States Proof Sets, 1983–1987
Price Realized:
45.00 USD / Lot
9.00 USD / ea
Lot 101 |

(5) United States Proof Sets, 1981-1985
(5) United States Proof Sets, 1981-1985
Price Realized:
55.00 USD / Lot
11.00 USD / ea
Lot 102 |

(4) U.S. Mint Proof Sets: 1990, 1993, 1995, 1998
(4) U.S. Mint Proof Sets: 1990, 1993, 1995, 1998
Price Realized:
36.00 USD / Lot
9.00 USD / ea
Lot 103 |

(5) United States Proof Sets: 1979-1982
(5) United States Proof Sets: 1979-1982
Price Realized:
30.00 USD / Lot
6.00 USD / ea
Lot 104 |

(5) U.S. Proof Sets: 1979, 1981, 1982, 1983, 1986
(5) U.S. Proof Sets: 1979, 1981, 1982, 1983, 1986
Price Realized:
40.00 USD / Lot
8.00 USD / ea
Lot 105 |

(5) United States Proof Sets, 1975–1979
(5) United States Proof Sets, 1975–1979
Price Realized:
40.00 USD / Lot
8.00 USD / ea
Lot 106 |

(4) U.S. Mint Proof Sets: 1986, 1990, 1991, 1998
(4) U.S. Mint Proof Sets: 1986, 1990, 1991, 1998
Price Realized:
32.00 USD / Lot
8.00 USD / ea
Lot 107 |

(4) United States Proof Sets: (2) 1968, 1969, 1973
(4) United States Proof Sets: (2) 1968, 1969, 1973
Price Realized:
32.00 USD / Lot
8.00 USD / ea
Lot 108 |

1928 United States $1 Red Seal Note
1928 United States $1 Red Seal Note
Price Realized:
160.00 USD
Lot 109 |

1913 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel
1913 Type 2 Buffalo Nickel
Price Realized:
19.00 USD
Lot 110 |

(20) US Indian Head Cents, 1880–1899
(20) US Indian Head Cents, 1880–1899
Price Realized:
55.00 USD
Lot 111 |

1913 D Type 2 Buffalo Nickel
1913 D Type 2 Buffalo Nickel
Price Realized:
50.00 USD
Lot 112 |

1914, 1915, 1916, 1917 Buffalo Nickels
1914, 1915, 1916, 1917 Buffalo Nickels
Price Realized:
37.50 USD
Lot 113 |

Lincoln Wheat Cent Rolls
Lincoln Wheat Cent Rolls
Price Realized:
50.00 USD
Lot 114 |

Six Walking Liberty Half Dollars
Six Walking Liberty Half Dollars
Price Realized:
150.00 USD / Lot
25.00 USD / ea
Lot 115 |

Series 1875 U.S. 25 Cent Fractional Currency Note
Series 1875 U.S. 25 Cent Fractional Currency Note
Price Realized:
60.00 USD
Lot 116 |

(3) Buffalo Nickels: 1936, 1937, 1938D,
(3) Buffalo Nickels: 1936, 1937, 1938D,
Price Realized:
6.00 USD
Lot 117 |

1937-S Buffalo Nickel NNC MS-66
1937-S Buffalo Nickel NNC MS-66
Price Realized:
15.00 USD
Lot 118 |

1934 Lincoln Wheat Cent MS65 RD NGC
1934 Lincoln Wheat Cent MS65 RD NGC
Price Realized:
20.00 USD
Lot 119 |

1936-D Buffalo Nickel MS-66 NNC Certified
1936-D Buffalo Nickel MS-66 NNC Certified
Price Realized:
11.00 USD
Lot 120 |

6 Walking Liberty Half Dollars, 1942 - 1944
6 Walking Liberty Half Dollars, 1942 - 1944
Price Realized:
150.00 USD / Lot
25.00 USD / ea
Lot 121 |

1897 Indian Head Cent MS61 Red & Brown (PCI)
1897 Indian Head Cent MS61 Red & Brown (PCI)
Price Realized:
11.00 USD
Lot 122 |

Series 1935A US $1 Silver Certificate, Blue Seal
Series 1935A US $1 Silver Certificate, Blue Seal
Price Realized:
16.00 USD
Lot 123 |

1935 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCI Certified
1935 Buffalo Nickel MS64 PCI Certified
Price Realized:
12.00 USD
Lot 124 |

1863 Indian Head Cent, AU55 (PCI)
1863 Indian Head Cent, AU55 (PCI)
Price Realized:
27.50 USD
Lot 125 |

1942-43-44 Walking Liberty Half Dollars, 6 Total
1942-43-44 Walking Liberty Half Dollars, 6 Total
Price Realized:
150.00 USD / Lot
25.00 USD / ea
Lot 126 |

1930 S Buffalo Nickel, AU-55 IGS Grading
1930 S Buffalo Nickel, AU-55 IGS Grading
Price Realized:
11.00 USD
Lot 127 |

1937 Buffalo Nickel, MS64 (PCI) Graded Coin
1937 Buffalo Nickel, MS64 (PCI) Graded Coin
Price Realized:
6.00 USD
Lot 128 |

6 Jefferson Nickels
6 Jefferson Nickels
Price Realized:
32.50 USD
Lot 129 |

(4) Canadian Mint Sets: 1968, 1969, 1970, 1971
(4) Canadian Mint Sets: 1968, 1969, 1970, 1971
Price Realized:
20.00 USD / Lot
5.00 USD / ea
Lot 130 |

1938-D Buffalo Nickel MS63 (NGC)
1938-D Buffalo Nickel MS63 (NGC)
Price Realized:
9.00 USD
Lot 131 |

1964 Canadian Nickel ICCS MS60, Extra Waterline
1964 Canadian Nickel ICCS MS60, Extra Waterline
Price Realized:
19.00 USD
Lot 132 |

1902 Canada Nickel, ICCS MS-62
1902 Canada Nickel, ICCS MS-62
Price Realized:
22.50 USD
Lot 133 |

Canada 1948 Nickel, ICCS MS-63
Canada 1948 Nickel, ICCS MS-63
Price Realized:
15.00 USD
Lot 134 |

1943 Canada 1 Cent, ICCS MS-64 Red
1943 Canada 1 Cent, ICCS MS-64 Red
Price Realized:
14.00 USD
Lot 135 |

1923 Canada One Cent Coin, ICCS EF-40
1923 Canada One Cent Coin, ICCS EF-40
Price Realized:
22.50 USD
Lot 178 |

8 US One Dollar Silver Certificates
8 US One Dollar Silver Certificates
Price Realized:
17.00 USD
Lot 179 |

(8) $1 Silver Certificate Notes Series 1935 US
(8) $1 Silver Certificate Notes Series 1935 US
Price Realized:
17.00 USD
Lot 180 |

U.S. Silver and Red Seal Notes, $1-$5, 7pcs
U.S. Silver and Red Seal Notes, $1-$5, 7pcs
Price Realized:
22.50 USD
Lot 181 |

Older Stock Transfer Stamps, 1924 Oak Hill Map
Older Stock Transfer Stamps, 1924 Oak Hill Map
Price Realized:
3.00 USD
Lot 182 |

2003 Missouri State Quarter Set United States
2003 Missouri State Quarter Set United States
Price Realized Not Uploaded
Lot 183 |

Trading Cards and Super Bowl XXV
Trading Cards and Super Bowl XXV
Price Realized:
4.00 USD
Lot 184 |

10 US Mercury Dimes
10 US Mercury Dimes
Price Realized:
42.50 USD
Lot 185 |

10 Mercury Dimes United States Silver Coins
10 Mercury Dimes United States Silver Coins
Price Realized:
42.50 USD
Lot 186 |

10 Mercury Dimes 90 Silver US Coins
10 Mercury Dimes 90 Silver US Coins
Price Realized:
45.00 USD
Lot 187 |

Ten Mercury Dimes United States Silver Coins
Ten Mercury Dimes United States Silver Coins
Price Realized:
45.00 USD
Lot 188 |

Ten Mercury Dimes
Ten Mercury Dimes
Price Realized:
42.50 USD
Lot 189 |

1875-S US 20 Cent Piece
1875-S US 20 Cent Piece
Price Realized:
75.00 USD
Lot 190 |

Kermit the Frog .999 1 Troy OZ Silver Ingot
Kermit the Frog .999 1 Troy OZ Silver Ingot
Price Realized:
65.00 USD
Lot 191 |

(10) 1860's 2-Cent Pieces
(10) 1860's 2-Cent Pieces
Price Realized:
80.00 USD
Lot 192 |

(2) $1 Silver Certificates
(2) $1 Silver Certificates
Price Realized:
16.00 USD
Lot 193 |

(18) Ancient Coins
(18) Ancient Coins
Price Realized:
140.00 USD
Lot 194 |

(5) 1858 Flying Eagle Cents
(5) 1858 Flying Eagle Cents
Price Realized:
65.00 USD / Lot
13.00 USD / ea
Lot 195 |

(5) Series 1957 $1 Silver Certificates
(5) Series 1957 $1 Silver Certificates
Price Realized:
15.00 USD
Lot 196 |

Series 1923 Large Silver Certificate
Series 1923 Large Silver Certificate
Price Realized:
22.50 USD
Lot 197 |

1935, 1937, 1954 Canadian $1 Notes
1935, 1937, 1954 Canadian $1 Notes
Price Realized:
50.00 USD
Lot 198 |

Series 1923 Large $1 Silver Certificate
Series 1923 Large $1 Silver Certificate
Price Realized:
50.00 USD
Lot 199 |

1/2 .999 Silver Troy Oz Batman Ingot with Box
1/2 .999 Silver Troy Oz Batman Ingot with Box
Price Realized:
47.50 USD
Lot 200 |

1899 US $1 Silver Certificate
1899 US $1 Silver Certificate
Price Realized:
42.50 USD
Lot 201 |

(7) 1800's US Silver Coins
(7) 1800's US Silver Coins
Price Realized:
42.50 USD
Lot 202 |

(6) 1950's - 1970's $1 and $2 Notes
(6) 1950's - 1970's $1 and $2 Notes
Price Realized:
11.00 USD
Lot 203 |

Walking Liberty Half Dollar Pendant in Bezel
Walking Liberty Half Dollar Pendant in Bezel
Price Realized:
30.00 USD
Lot 204 |

(12) Mixed coins
(12) Mixed coins
Price Realized:
27.50 USD
Lot 205 |

(26) Ancient and Foreign Coins
(26) Ancient and Foreign Coins
Price Realized:
35.00 USD
Lot 206 |

Precious & Semi-Precious stones w/ Some 14k Gold
Precious & Semi-Precious stones w/ Some 14k Gold
Price Realized:
70.00 USD
Lot 207 |

1921 Morgan Dollar Sterling Silver Money Clip
1921 Morgan Dollar Sterling Silver Money Clip
Price Realized:
55.00 USD
Lot 208 |

1817 & 1839 US Large Cents
1817 & 1839 US Large Cents
Price Realized:
36.00 USD / Lot
18.00 USD / ea
Lot 209 |

1832 Silver Bust Half Dollar
1832 Silver Bust Half Dollar
Price Realized:
70.00 USD
Lot 210 |

1916 - 1921 Mercury Dimes (13 total)
1916 - 1921 Mercury Dimes (13 total)
Price Realized:
47.50 USD
Lot 211 |

1832 Silver Bust Half Dollar
1832 Silver Bust Half Dollar
Price Realized:
65.00 USD
Lot 212 |

1854, 1858, 1877 Seated Liberty Silver Halves
1854, 1858, 1877 Seated Liberty Silver Halves
Price Realized:
97.50 USD / Lot
32.50 USD / ea
Lot 213 |

(2) Seated Quarters and (1) Seated Half Dollar
(2) Seated Quarters and (1) Seated Half Dollar
Price Realized:
35.00 USD
Lot 214 |

1878-S Morgan Silver Dollar
1878-S Morgan Silver Dollar
Price Realized:
70.00 USD
Lot 215 |

1849, (2) 1853 Large Cents
1849, (2) 1853 Large Cents
Price Realized:
24.00 USD / Lot
8.00 USD / ea
Lot 216 |

(4) Civil War Tokens and Indian Head Cents, 1860's
(4) Civil War Tokens and Indian Head Cents, 1860's
Price Realized:
6.00 USD
Lot 217 |

(4) Walking Liberty Half Dollars
(4) Walking Liberty Half Dollars
Price Realized:
100.00 USD / Lot
25.00 USD / ea
Lot 218 |

1932 - 1937 Silver Washington Quarters (10 total)
1932 - 1937 Silver Washington Quarters (10 total)
Price Realized:
110.00 USD
Lot 219 |

1878 Morgan Silver Dollar
1878 Morgan Silver Dollar
Price Realized:
90.00 USD
Lot 220 |

(137) .999 Silver Gram Bars
(137) .999 Silver Gram Bars
Lot 221 |

1892-O Morgan Silver Dollar
1892-O Morgan Silver Dollar
Price Realized:
80.00 USD
Lot 222 |

18K and Stainless Bracelet
18K and Stainless Bracelet
Price Realized:
47.50 USD
Lot 223 |

Sterling Silver & 14K Gold Money Clip
Sterling Silver & 14K Gold Money Clip
Price Realized:
25.00 USD
Lot 224 |

1879-S Morgan Silver Dollar
1879-S Morgan Silver Dollar
Price Realized:
60.00 USD
Lot 225 |

1935A Hawaii $1 Silver Certificate
1935A Hawaii $1 Silver Certificate
Price Realized:
35.00 USD
Lot 226 |

1885-S Morgan Silver Dollar
1885-S Morgan Silver Dollar
Price Realized:
85.00 USD
Lot 227 |

1840, 1877, 1887 Seated Liberty Dimes
1840, 1877, 1887 Seated Liberty Dimes
Price Realized:
42.50 USD
Lot 228 |

Mixed Lot of Civil War Era Tokens & Coins
Mixed Lot of Civil War Era Tokens & Coins
Price Realized:
17.00 USD
Lot 229 |

1895, 1897, 1915 Barber Silver Quarters
1895, 1897, 1915 Barber Silver Quarters
Price Realized:
37.50 USD
Lot 230 |

40 Rings of Mixed Materials
40 Rings of Mixed Materials
Price Realized:
80.00 USD
Lot 231 |

Unheated White Sapphire
Unheated White Sapphire
Price Realized:
360.00 USD
Lot 232 |

1878 CC Morgan Silver Dollar
1878 CC Morgan Silver Dollar
Price Realized:
75.00 USD
Lot 233 |

1883 "Without Cents" V Nickel
1883 "Without Cents" V Nickel
Price Realized:
9.00 USD
Lot 234 |

1860's 3 Cent Pieces (5 total)
1860's 3 Cent Pieces (5 total)
Price Realized:
75.00 USD
Lot 235 |

1878-S Morgan Silver Dollar
1878-S Morgan Silver Dollar
Price Realized:
85.00 USD
Lot 236 |

(5) Coins From the 1800's
(5) Coins From the 1800's
Price Realized:
35.00 USD
Lot 999 |

Handmade Wooden Model Barn with Equipment Shed
Handmade Wooden Model Barn with Equipment Shed
Price Realized:
120.00 USD